Monday, 28 May 2018

My Time with the Fourth Doctor


It's been a loooonng time, but we're finally here.  Time to look back on our time with the longest serving  (on screen) Time Lord.

Twelfth Season
The twelfth season saw a handover from long time producer Barry Letts to the young upstart Phillip Hinchcliffe.  To ease the transition, this was to be somewhat of a Greatest Hits season - to help the new Doctor find his feet and give the audience something familiar to cling onto. 

As it happens, it provided some of the most memorable and iconic stories in the whole of Doctor Who, notably Genesis of the Daleks which came about when Terry Nation was forced to write something new.

The dynamic in the TARDIS was pretty good too, with Harry being the lovably buffoon, and Sarah the feisty adventurous one, with the Doctor backing them up with the brains.

Thirteenth Season
Now that Tom Baker has found his feet, and Phillip Hinchcliffe and Robert Holmes are free to spread their wings, we now enter the golden age of Doctor Who. 

The claimed "gothic" style of storytelling was in full swing here and brought the kind of stories that interested adults and terrified kids (in a good way). Re-tellings of Forbidden Planet, the Mummy, Frankenstein and more provided a good basis that never felt cheesy or overused - it all felt like a homage rather than a rip-off and was very, very welcome.  The dynamic between The Doctor and Sarah was also spot on, and could have happily gone on until the end of Tom's reign.

Fourteenth Season
The first half of this season is a little laboured, but the departure of Sarah Jane is incredibly moving. Once she's gone, the season gets back its stride with the addition of Leela and we get some really great stories to round it all off, returning once again to the victorian gothic to provide well rounded stories.

Fifteenth Season
No thanks to Mary Whitehouse, Phillip Hinchclife had departed mid-way through the previous season and Graham Williams took over.  Whilst he was working on the shceduled stories, things were fine and we got arguably the best doctor who ever made in "The Horror of Fang Rock".  The show went a different direction under Williams' leadership, refusing to re-enter earth, but didn't have the budget to make top quality alien environments, therefore ending up laughable and painful.  At least the inclusion of K9 made things better with the kiddies.

Sixteenth Season
Graham Williams' ambitious season long story arc - the key to time.  Sometimes a hit, often a miss, this effort ultimately ran out of steam and limped over the finish line.  Mary Tamm as Romana was a breath of fresh air, but she quickly realised the character was being played down from her potential and made a quick exit.

Tom was also getting far more frustrated than he had before. Being continually refused the opportunity to work alone, he began to see things a lot differently than Graham Williams and the tension just built and built.

Seventeenth Season
If not for the onset of Douglas Adams as script editor for this season, Tom Baker might have left long before he did.  As it happened, the stories in this season took a more humorous twist, and Tom was given license to act the fool more and more, sometimes to the detriment of the story.

Still, a lot of interesting stories came out of the season and it found a way to be fun once more as opposed to just plain drab.

Eighteenth Season 
The departure of Graham Williams and Douglas Adams ushered in the final producer of the show until its cancellation.  John Nathan-Turner.  A man with big ideas and high ambitions but a ruthless scatter-gun approach to show running. With the new broom policy, he cut swathes of the production team from the show and started aftesh with up-to date music, visuals and looks.  He was responsible for a new theme tune, costume (with ? on the lapels) and the death of K9. 

All of this, coupled with the general disagreement of the shows direction, was too much for Tom and he decided to call it quits.  Calling his bluff, the production team took him up on it.  They would decide on a younger version of the main character, a controversial choice and the nation would be poised on their seats, watching to see if the new version of the Doctor would be a success or a dismal failure.

The Doctor 
If you had to describe the Fourth Doctor in one word, it couldn't be more perfect than "eccentric" and that's just what Tom Baker was.  He often cites that he was just playing himself, with big shoes to fill from Jon Pertwee, Tom immediately sprang to life with a twinkle in his eye, winning the hearts of the nation. 

Through the seven years of playing Doctor Who, Tom's Doctor goes through three distinct phases - dry wit, brooding alien, cosmic clown and back to brooding alien at the very end (but a lot grumpier).

I have to say, even though I enjoyed City of Death and Shada immensely, I do prefer the Fouth Doctor in his dry-wit and brooding alien era.  When he's serious, Tom Baker can provide an immense amount of pathos which really sells the situation that would otherwise be hokey.

The final story sees him very sombre and almost returned to the way he was in Pyramids of Mars, but this time, he's somehow mournful. It's likely that he knows he's going to die via the watcher, and as a result he's a lot more snappy and irritable than before.

Given how long Tom played the Doctor, it should be absolutely heart wrenching to see him go, but it's set up in such a way as to be fascinated as to what's coming next. Still, for generations afterwards, people all cite the mighty Tom Baker as "their Doctor" and rightly so.  He left behind a great legacy and huge boots to fill. It was just sad that he didn't get to go out as he wanted to.

Favourite Moment

Over seven years of playing the Doctor, there's almost too many to choose from.  You could say the entire speech with Scarlioni in the City of Death if you wanted humour, or the "I walk in eternity" speech from Pyramids of Mars if you want to be melodramatic. For me, the real gem is the dilemma he faces in Genesis of the Daleks, when given the option of destroying the Daleks before they were even created, he worries over if he has the right to become a god and damn a race in its infancy.



Worst Moment

Whilst some stories dragged in almost every season, there cannot be any instances in the first five years of Tom's reign that even qualify for this (alright, the invisible enemy comes pretty close). 

Given the drabness of the Graham Williams' era, I'm tempted to announce something from there, but for all their faults, there is one that tops even those.  I chose the transformation scene in the Leisure Hive. Tom Baker HATED the thought of running around like an old man, and I see why.  It's pointless adds very little to the story and is purely a gimmick. He looks bored out of his mind and it transfers to the audience, believe me.



Favourite Story 

The Horror of Fang Rock

I so want to select the Talons of Weng-Chiang for this one. It's got the Victorian Gothic atmosphere in abundance, the sombre-doctor is mixed with a good amount of dry wit and outright humour from Jago and Lightfoot, and it's written by Bob Holmes, the greatest Doctor Who writer of them all.  But as good as that story is, it does tend to go on just an episode or two - too long.  In the very next story, they replicate everything great about the Talons, but keep it brief and suspenseful.  There's even a sub-plot, well thought out and communicated and the level of horror is genuinely good (at least until the ball of snot turns up at the very end).  This is my all time favourite Doctor Who story, and it deserves far far more recognition than it gets.


Worst Story

The Armageddon Factor

Some of the later editions of the Fourth Doctor certainly qualify, especially the ones where Christopher H Bidmead is trying to be clever and introduce the science as an interesting cause for the story in its own right.  I think ultimately, The Armageddon Factor pips stories like Logopolis and the Leisure Hive to the post because it's six episodes of tedium.  Allright, the first episode of the story is actually quite good, but it goes downhill fast from there.  It's a chore to sit through and the ending is so rushed as to be a massive anti-climax to the whole of the season.



Favourite Companion

Leela

As mentioned when we reminisced with the Third Doctor, I could easily choose Sarah Jane again for this, as I believe her dynamic only improved with Tom Baker.  As it happens all of the companions with the Fourth Doctor were quite good, yes, even Adric once Romana was out of the way. 

The one I will select though is Leela.  The eliza Doolittle approach to her character was fresh and interesting, and she added interesting interactions with people who she met and cultures unfamiliar to her.  There's also the nice outfit, but we won't go there.



Worst Companion

K9

An angel to some, a demon to others.  K9 was problematic for many reasons.  He was a know-it-all, he was a crutch for the Doctor to lean on to easily solve any problem including shooting baddies when needed.  K9 was a hindrance more than a help to the show and I never really liked him.  Yes, I said it.  Although, I must be the only person in the universe who likes K9 and Company and thought the theme tune was catchy!





Logopolis




4 Episodes
Aired between 28th February 1981 and 21st March 1981

Written by Christopher H Bidmead
Produced by John Nathan-Turner
Directed by Peter Grimwade

Synopsis

The Doctor and Adric are taking a tour of the TARDIS interior, noting that the ship is gradually decaying from its age when the Cloister Bell sounds.  The Doctor says it's a sign of impending doom.  He decides that the best thing to do is to give the TARDIS an overhaul, and fix the chameleon circuit whilst he's at it.


To do this, he takes them to a Police Box on earth in 1981, landing on top of it so that the real police box is transported inside the console room, and they can take the appropriate dimensions of the box that they'll need.


The Doctor's intent is to go to a place called Logopolis, where the scientists there will be able to use the dimensions he provides to effectively re-make the TARDIS from the ground up.


Little does the Doctor know however that the Master has done the exact same thing as him very shortly before (hinting at some form of telepathy between the Time Lords). This leads to a form of time loop where going in the doors of one TARDIS leads into the console room of the other.  The Doctor and Adric go off to find the Master in this recursive labyrinth.

Meanwhile, a young lady called Tegan Jovanka struggles with her old car to get to Heathrow Airport, where she's about to start her new job as an air hostess.  Her Aunty Vanessa is with her to help her along, but they get a flat tyre and are forced to pull up near the box.  Trying to call for help, Tegan enters the TARDIS and gets lost in the interior.


Whilst she does so, the Master nips out and kills Aunty Vanessa with his handy Tissue Compression Eliminator.  Why?  I don't know.

Not being able to find the Master, the Doctor decides on a bonkers plan to flush the Master out by opening the doors whilst at the bottom of the Thames.  Thankfully, the TARDIS actually materialises on a boat instead, missing target by mere feet.  As they inspect what went wrong, the Doctor sees a mysterious white figure.

He speaks to him alone and comes back looking very sombre.  He decides to go to Logopolis instead, taking Tegan inadvertently with them.



Once on Logopolis, they are greeted by the chief scientist known as the Monitor.  He assures them that he can use a very complex form of mathematics known as block transfer computation to re-design the TARDIS as requested.

Nyssa turns up and says that a friend of the Doctor's brought her here.  She's looking for her father who went missing.

It doesn't take long however for the master to begin messing things up, shrinking lots of Logopolitans, tricking Nyssa into believing he is still her father, and trying to sieze control of the planet by using a technological device to silence the Logopolitans from speaking their mathematical equations.


This backfires however, as it turns out, that the universe should have decayed and died a long time ago because it's something called a closed system (it's finite).  The Logopolitans have staved off the end of the universe by using a replica of the Pharos Project on Earth to effectively open up dimensions via CVE's (see Full Circle) thereby creating more and more "space" and keeping the system open, therefore staving off entropy.  Now that the Logopolitans cannot do that, the universe suddenly begins to die!

All this mayhem means that it's too late for Logopolis and the Doctor forces Adric, Nyssa and Tegan into the TARDIS which is taken by the mysterious white figure out of the known universe and time stream to keep them safe.


They watch helplessly as entire worlds and solar systems begin to blink out and die - one of them being Traken.

The Doctor meanwhile stays behind and is forced to work with the Master.


They determine that whilst the replica of the Pharos project is beyond saving, the data in its computer banks is still there, so the real Pharos project on Earth could be capable of restoring balance.  He, the Master and Tegan (who jumped ship) go to Earth and try to get to the control room on the radar dish.  Tegan gets left behind and finds Adric and Nyssa as they convince the white figure (they call the Watcher) to bring the TARDIS to Earth.

They look on helplessly as the Doctor and the Master get up to the dish.  They setup the dish to open up more CVE's and provide stability but the Master holds him at gunpoint, sending out an ultimatum to the universe that if they don't recognise his rule, he will close the CVE.  The Doctor sprints onto the gantry, trying to disconnect the cable that the Master would use to carry out his threat, but the Master re-aligns the dish tilting it.


The Doctor does disconnect the cable, but falls from the gantry in the process.


The companions race to the Doctor's side as he lies on the ground.  He says that "this is the end, but the moment has been prepared for" and reaches out to the mysterious white figure who then melds with him to regenerate into the next Doctor...





Trivia


  • The story was the brainchild of Christopher H Bidmead, who was going out as script editor because he'd had enough.  He thought of the idea from Keeper of Traken when the Master escapes from the Melkur in his TARDIS - so it was a TARDIS within a TARDIS.  The first instance of this though was of course, the Time Monster.
  • The watcher was meant to be mysterious and alluded to as the possible new form of the Master.  That's why he wasn't shown for the first couple of episodes. Unfortunately, the ending of the Keeper of Traken showed us everything and spoiled all the effort they went to on this
  • The character of Tegan was designed by John Nathan-Turner.  He created it because Australian broadcasting were talking about a co-production and he wanted to justify a jolly to Australia, so he put an Australian character in.  
  • When designing the character, JNT asked for the character to be called something like Tegan OR Jovanka, but that got muddled in the process and her full name became Tegan Jovanka.  
  • The house Tegan leaves actually belongs to one of the writers of Meglos.
  • Finally, we can't end this without talking about good old Tom.  This wasn't the ending he was hoping for, and he made sure everyone knew about it.  His general depression about the direction the show was going, and his recent illness all took their toll on him.  He was grouchy to the end, and whilst it was the end of an era, many of the crew would breathe a sigh of relief when he left


The Review

This is the end indeed. Tom Baker wanted it spectacular with high stakes, shooty lasers and big explosions.  Whilst that might have been a bit over the ever tightening budget, it could have been done something like it.

Now, if you're an intellectual and into scientific theory, then you'll probably think this review is dumbing things down or assume I just didn't "get it". That's not the case.  Oftentimes, we argue that Doctor Who plays it too safe and child-friendly for the audience and they can afford to do more high brow things and explain more complicated processes.  I totally agree with that, but in my opinion, Logopolis does so at the expense of drama.

The scientific concept of entropy destroying the universe unless you open up other dimensions is cool (and is supposedly used by Isaac Asimov himself as the basis of a story).  Having a recursive loop of TARDIS' is cool even if it's been done before, and if done right, the shrink-killing of lots of people could be terrifying.  Indeed, Logopolis has arguably the highest body count of any Doctor Who story yet told, it's just that most of them are off screen and not referred to other than lights of stars blinking out.

My problem with Logopolis is that it's full of techno-babble.  Whether real or made up, I don't care. It's just too dense to get any enjoyment from it, and it's sold in a way that it practically pauses for you to be impressed when someone spouts out a long and complicated theory.  It's frankly impossible to relate to. The only character you can do that with is Tegan who spends all her time either decrying the usefulness of men, or crying about the fact that she's hopelessly lost and wants to go home.

To add to the misery. the Master is chaotic at best, having no real motive and just going with the flow, trying his hand at a couple of evil schemes just because. I mean, he could have been joking about the CVE, but how would he realistically enforce his rule?  How would he know if they'd refuse his rule?

At least you can say that the main actors were reasonably good at their performances, but the supporting ones - especially the guards and policemen were agonisingly bad.

Rating 

4 out of 10

Rewatchability Factor

4 out of 10

Watch this if you liked...


  • Planet of Fire

Friday, 18 May 2018

The Keeper of Traken




4 Episodes
Aired between 31st January 1981 and 21st February 1981

Written by Johnny Byrne
Produced by John Nathan-Turner
Directed by John Black

Synopsis

Whilst on their way to Gallifrey, the Doctor and Adric are visited by an old man known as the Keeper of Traken.  His planet (Traken) has a society based on everyone "being terribly nice to each other." This niceness has been infused in some kind of matrix style technology that immobilises any evil people that set foot on the planet.


The keeper asks the Doctor to help as he's almost dying and that will diminish the power on the planet and put them at risk.  The Doctor is asked to help the transition.

On Traken itself, the citizens celebrate the marriage of two of their rulers - members of the consul that runs the society - Kassia and Tremas.

Kassia has looked after one of the evil forces that has been immobilised in the gardens for many years.  They call it the Melkur.  Now they are married, Tremas' daughter, Nyssa is put in charge of looking after the Melkur.  No one knows however that Kassia is secretly despairing about the likelyhood of her new husband, Tremas, being chosen as the next keeper, being sent into the ether of the machine and effectively widowing her straight away.  The Melkur talks to her and forces her to start helping it, in return promising that it will make sure Tremas is kept safe.


As part of the Melkur's plan, it kills a guard near the gardens, just before the TARDIS arrives.


The Doctor and Adric are arrested for the murder, and when they try to go and get confirmation from the Keeper, the Melkur turns up.  The Keeper blurts out that evil has invaded the sanctum and they confuse the Doctor and Adric for being the object of that cry.  Despite this, Tremas acknowledges their clear intelligence, and uses them as prisoners under house arrest to help investigate the rise in strange readings of evil he's been taking in the area.

There's a couple of episodes that involve running back and forth from the palace, the garden and Tremas' house, and it's all related to either proving Adric and The Doctor aren't evil, doing something to find the TARDIS (that has been displaced in time by the Melkur) or with Kassia doing more and more shady things to ensure Tremas' safety.  This includes putting on a neck brace that gives her laser beam eyes, and allows the Melkur to see through her eyes and control her.


Ultimately, with the help of Kassia unknowingly sacrificing herself, the Melkur is placed in the matrix machine once the current Keeper of Traken dies and is turned into the new keeper.  He quickly assumes control and places Tremas and the Doctor under arrest.  The Doctor quickly works out what happens and he works with Tremas to mess up the matrix machine.  Before he can complete the work, he is captured and taken to the Melkur.  He is taken inside the matrix style machine, and discovers that the Melkur is actually a TARDIS and the real villain is the Master!


Slipping under the radar, Nyssa and Adric work together to build a servo-shutoff machine and mess up the matrix, allowing the Doctor to escape.



The machine messes up and destroys the Melkur, and thinking the threat is dealt with, the Doctor and Adric leave.  The Master however, had his own TARDIS within the Melkur TARDIS and he materialises on Traken, capturing Tremas and using his body to regenerate.


Laughing, the Master goes back into his TARDIS and dematerialises.

Trivia


  • Geoffrey Beevers was cast as the Master, unfortunately used only once. His costume was the same cloak as was used in the Deadly Assassin, but the mast was so deteriorated that they couldn't use it.  Beevers preferred to use his own face anyway so he could emote better.  As a side note, Geoffrey Beevers is the husband of Carolyn John (Liz Shaw).
  • As was typical of John Nathan-Turner, the Master was a last minute addition.  He suddenly decided that the show needed his return and made the writer and Chris Bidmead find a way to explain it in the script.
  • Another addition to the crew was Nyssa herself.  She was only meant to appear in this story, but the production team were so impressed with her acting that they asked if she wanted to stay on for a bit and become a companion
  • Actually, the above point, whilst true is not the full story.  There was method behind JNT's madness, as he had actually asked Liz Sladen to reprise her role as Sarah-Jane Smith, and Louise Jameson for Leela.  Both turned the option down, leaving him with a gap as he saw it.  Ultimately, he decided (probably randomly) that the show needed not one companion but three.


The Review

And so we come into the home straight of the Fourth Doctor's run.  At first it does feel nostalgic, with the Doctor and Adric lamenting the loss of Romana and K9, but oddly enough, thanks to Johnny Bryne's dialogue, we get to see a very brief and massively surprising glimpse of what life on the TARDIS could have been like with just Adric and the Doctor.  There's no hint of the whiny boy we would come to know, and the way he reacts to the Doctor is very funny and entertaining.

Anyway, on with the rest of the story.

The story set up, although having a lot of exposition at the beginning, it had a lot of good ideas and gave the sense of a genuine world with distinct customs. This story promises epic scope or at the very least multiple sub-plots or character arcs.  It doesn't quite live up to that though in my opinion as it gets bogged down in running backwards and forwards, and stupid inspectors getting knocked unconscious every three minutes.

The inclusion of the Master, whilst novel to see, is also confusing.  There's not really enough of a justification as to why he's there, or why he's spent years and years just sat in his TARDIS in the garden of Traken.

I suppose Nyssa doesn't show any real promise as a companion, but it's interesting to note that the Doctor never actually chose her as a companion himself.

This story has a lot to offer, even if it's slightly confusing at times.

Rating

8 out of 10

Rewatchability Factor

5 out of 10

Watch this if you liked...


  • Trial of a Time Lord