Four episodes
Aired between 1st February 1983 and 9th February 1983
Written by Peter Grimwade
Produced by John Nathan-Turner
Directed by Peter Moffatt
Synopsis
Brigadier Alistair Gordon Lethbridge Stewart has retired from UNIT and is now a maths teacher at an all boys public school. One day, he has his car stolen by a very mischievous boy called Turlough (who just happens to be an alien, stranded on the planet Earth).
Having stolen the car, Turlough drives the car recklessly, until he inevitably crashes it. Whilst unconscious, Turlough is contacted by the Black Guardian who offers him a way off the planet, provided that he helps him kill the Doctor, someone who the Black Guardian insists is evil. Turlough agrees and is brought back to consciousness.
As this is happening, the TARDIS is caught in a Warp Elipse and ends up materialising on board a spaceship that's close to a space liner. The Doctor, Nyssa and Tegan all go to investigate.
Turlough awakens back at the school in bed. He finds a crystal by the bed which allows him to communicate with the Black Guardian.
The Guardian instructs Turlough to go into the gardens near a monument where he finds a transmat. He is taken onboard the space liner. He soon meets up with the TARDIS crew and introduces himself.
The Doctor discovers that this liner is like a ghost ship, abandoned, but trapped in a perpetual orbit. He thinks that the transmat signal is what's trapping the TARDIS in place and he goes down to Earth with Turlough in the transmat to try and repair the signal and thus free his ship. Whilst he's busy working, Turlough picks up a rock and is about to kill the Doctor, but the transmat electronics explode and throw them both back. The resulting blast shifts the TARDIS to a different time.
Seemingly stranded, the Doctor heads to the school. Having missed his opportunity, Turlough follows. They eventually me the Brigadier, but he has no recollection of the Doctor, and confirms this is 1983. It turns out there is some kind of trauma that caused him to block out his memory and he eventually comes to recognise his old friend. To his surprise though, he remembers Tegan, a girl he's never met before.
Leaving the TARDIS, Nyssa and Tegan find the transmat capsule has a wounded man in it. Nyssa strongly believes that it's the Doctor and whilst she looks after him, she sends Tegan to go and get help. Tegan goes to the school and finds the Brigadier, but discovers that they've jumped back to 1977.
This revelation revealed to the Doctor from the Brigadier's retelling shows him that the girls and the TARDIS are safe, they just have to find out where they went.
The man, now in the TARDIS claims he's the Doctor, but looks different - Nyssa believes he's regenerated. The "Doctor" says his body's failing and the regeneration isn't working and they need to get to the Space Cruiser so he can stabilise. Tegan doesn't believe it is the Doctor but Nyssa and the Brigadier overrule her.
Back in 1983, the Doctor, Old Brigadier and Turlough use the transmat signal to bring them in alignment with Nyssa, Tegan and the young Brigadier, by effectively going to the Spaceship in 1977. The Doctor warns the Brigadier he must be careful not to see his younger self and especially not to touch him as it could cause a paradox.
There's a lot of running around corridors and missing each other. Turlough finds a bunch of ring wraiths in stasis chambers and discovers that the man pretending to be the Doctor is one of them. He is called Mawdryn, and they were a bunch of scientists, trying to steal the secret of regeneration from the Time Lords. All that happened though was that they became immortal, but frequently mutated and condemned themselves to a lifetime of suffering. They now travel on the ship. It approaches a new location every few years and they resume their search for a cure.
The Black Guardian says that the Doctor is about to die from the circumstances, and instructs Turlough to stop the Brigadier's from meeting.
He attempts to do this by trapping him in the secret stasis chamber that the scientists slept in.
The scientists have obviously left the room by then. They all gather by the Doctor and tell their tale of woe. Mawdryn begs the Doctor to help them die by providing enough energy to power their regeneration machines. The Doctor refuses however because it would drain him of all his remaining regenerations and he would no longer be a Time Lord.
The Doctor tries to leave in the TARDIS, but soon discovers that Tegan and Nyssa are infected by the same condition as Mawdryn and the other scientists (through physical contact with him?) The Doctor has no choice but to return to the cruiser and agree to help.
The young Brigadier manages to find his way out of the stasis chamber and finds Mawdryn and the crew. They try to send him to Earth in the transmat, but it fails and he returns.
The Black Guardian screams at Turlough to find the Brigadier and stop him, but ultimately, the Brigadier does encounter himself and as they touch hands, there's a blinding discharge of energy and what would otherwise be catastrophic, is instead transferred into Mawdryn's machine and provides the energy to kill them, rather than draining the Doctor.
The paradox it turns out was responsible for the Brigadier's loss of memory. The Doctor uses the transmat to return the unconscious Brigadier's to their respective times. As he's doing this, Turlough (who ran away when the Brigadier met himself) sneaks on board the TARDIS and tries to hijack it, but the crew catch him in the act. He passes it off non-nonchalantly as wanting to join the crew. The girls aren't impressed but they agree to take Turlough with them.
Trivia
- This was Peter Grimwade's second attempt at writing for Doctor Who after the disastrous story (in my opinion) Time Flight. It took the place of a story called the Space Whale (not dissimilar to Series 5 episode, The Beast Below). It was a story that was long anticipated, but never seemed to get everything in place. Turlough was meant to be a colonist on the ship.
- As with all stories in Season 20, this one featured a key aspect of the shows past - actually it had 2 - the Black Guardian and The Brigadier.
- The Brigadier was actually the production team's third choice however. They first approached William Russell to reprise his role as Ian Chesterton (a much better fit as a maths teacher), and when he was unavailable, they went to Ian Marter (Harry Sullivan). Ultimately, it came down to Nicholas Courtney and he jumped at the chance.
- A future Eastender's regular was the girl who played young Nyssa
- Mark Strickson (Turlough) had blonde hair at the time. The production team didn't want him to clash with the star of the show so they proposed that he shaved his head. Strickson refused unless they paid him a ton of money in compensation, so they came to a compromise of dying it ginger
The Review
This is a Doctor Who story that I want to love, but always has something there that disappoints. It's got a spark of something but never seems to reach the highs that it should.
The plot itself is a little bit complicated, but that's okay because it tackles something that is glaringly obvious for a show such as this. It heavily features the intricacies of time travel and the implications that might have. The 1960's audience of the show would not have been ready for that - they were revelling in the Dan Dare space adventure feel of the show. The Third and Forth Doctor's runs helped us get to this place, but ultimately this was a good indicator that the needs of the audience had grown beyond that of a children's show.
Similarly, a character that's effectively a boy being manipulated by the forces of evil to become an agent of the Doctor's destruction is really interesting.
The music has never been as innovative and enhanced the scene it's in since the Sea Devils (the Visitation may be an exception).
Finally, the nostalgia of the Brigadier after him being away for seven years is welcome. The black guardian less so, seeing as he appeared like, once, for five minutes in the show. Still, his utter blackness and ruthlessness should be akin to the devil himself and the Doctor pitting himself against something so powerful should be monumental.
The execution of all of this though is quite frankly clunky at times. The acting is waaaay overboard. The costumes are a put off, and the music, whilst great (with the exception of the car driving music) is so overused that it becomes downright annoying, almost annoying as Turlough himself.
Eric Saward knew the problems in hindsight, but I'm not sure they would have been able to fix the big issue of Turlough constantly trying to kill the Doctor and failing without writing him out altogether.
This is a story that's definitely worth a watch, and if you can filter out all the repetition and really invest in the character's struggles, then you'll enjoy it. For me, it shows promise, but it's a bit of hard work.
Rating
7 out of 10
Re-watchability Factor
5 out of 10
Watch this if you liked...
- The Two Doctors
- Father's Day (Doctor Who, Series 1)